Inventors Sue Copycats Successfully
published originally in NZHerald.co.nz
A New Zealand toy firm that sells a globally successful water balloon toy has won $18 million in a legal fight against a company that copied its product.
Zuru Toys’ Bunch O Balloons is a device that fills more than 100 self-tying water balloons simultaneously.
Zuru was founded in Cambridge in 2004 by Mat Mowbray, who owns the business along with his siblings, Nick and Anna.
Zuru has revenue of more than $500 million, helped along by the sales of more than three billion individual water balloons in the past year alone.
In April Zuru filed a lawsuit for patent infringement against Telebrands, a US telemarketing company, for products that appeared to be a knock-off of its Bunch O Balloons.
Zuru has already won three preliminary injunctions against Telebrands for its balloon products range, including its Battle Balloons, Balloon Bonanza and Easy Einstein products.
A jury has now found in Zuru’s favour over the Battle Balloon product line, including Balloon Bonanza HD and Battle Balloon Color Burst.
Zuru was awarded lost profits and damages of US$12,250,000 (about $18m).
Chief operating officer Anna Mowbray said the company was committed to “continuously fighting what we believe are knock-off companies like Telebrands who try to undercut inventors and claim innovations as their own”.
“We are confident that the US legal system will help us continue to send this message.
Zuru has two additional cases against Telebrands, involving the Balloon Bonanza and Easy Einsteins products, which it says are also copies of its products.
Lab testing on samples of Telebrands’ Easy Einsteins product had also showed it contained toxic chemicals well in excess of legal limits for children’s toys.
Telebrands has argued that following the lab tests it was already withdrawing the product from the market.